I had a Damascus Road type conversion experience when I was 18. I began attending the high school Christian Club, was baptized in a Baptist church less than a year later. While finishing my undergraduate and graduate degrees, I was the leader of a Christian parachurch organization and was responsible for leading weekly bible studies, prayer meetings, outreaches, discipleship and special events (concerts, films, etc). I lead a short-term missions team overseas while in graduate school and then decided to work part-time in environmental consulting and attend Seminary full-time. Shortly after finishing a 1-year graduate program in Biblical Studies (Multnomah Biblical Seminary), I lived overseas in southeast Asia as a science teacher and Resident Director (Dorm Parent) at a Christian International school for over 3 years. I have been married 16 years to a wonderful woman and have 2 beautiful children…and I no longer believe the bible is the literal inspired words of God.
Let me clarify, with some examples: I don’t believe that God drowned the inhabitants of planet earth with a flood, and at the same time saved Noah and his family inside a large ark. It’s a story. In fact, I NEVER believed this story to be literally true. Not even in the most ardent, zealous, sincere moments of my newfound faith or in seminary or on the mission field or when i was discipling young men on the university campus, did I ever really believe this. There are so many other examples: Ten Commandments inscribed on stone by God on Mt. Sinai, Herod ordering the massacre of first-born males after Jesus’ birth, Adam & Eve in a literal Garden of Eden with a talking snake, etc.
What EXACTLY do I mean when I say “I don’t believe these things?” If I was transported back in time with a video camera to when these events were supposed to have occurred, I would not be able to capture some of these events on film because they simply did not happen. In other cases, I would be able to record the events, but they did not occur exactly the way the Bible portrays them. Also, they are not myths that have some profound, spiritual, God-inspired embedded truths that we can learn from. They never happened. They are made up stories. Any truth that we derive from these stories, are extracted by each of us as we impart and impose some subjective meaning to these made up stories.
What about Jesus? Christianity? I thought you said you were a Christian? I think many (not all) of the things in the new testament actually happened. They sayings of Jesus and the chronology of his life are based on at least 20 years of oral tradition before they were written down. I view the letters of the new testament as letters from Christ-followers to fellow Christ-followers at that time, with the intention to encourage and instruct along the way of their faith journey. They were following Jesus together and trying to figure things out as they went along, and they wrote down stuff that they thought was important and helpful, as best as they could remember.
What do these writings mean to me today? I consider these new testament letters to be an outdated, wrinkled, torn, coffee-stained map for my faith adventure, handed down each generation from the original courageous, sincere, adventurous fellow Christ-followers. It’s all I have. It will have to be enough to get me to where I want to go and help me become the man I want to become. It’s not the ONLY source of direction or instruction or spiritual growth for me. I love www.ted.com/talks to hear about brilliant people making a difference with their lives. I love other good books, good friends, comedians, movies, lectures, seminars and podcasts. I think some of the things my fellow Christ-followers said 2000 years ago really don’t apply to my life today at all (e.g., letters of instructions to slaves, ideas on the appropriate behavior for women, etc.). It applied to their lives, but not mine. The old testament instructions on hygiene, safe foods, etc. are absolutely useless to me, and if read today in a medical school would just seem archaic and irrelevant…because they are. Some of those ideas helped at the time and made sense, but not anymore. Why would keeping women silent in church be in any way relevant to me? If you know anything about church history, you soon realize that there are many letters from fellow Christ-followers that did not make it into the “official” book of letters in the new testament.
I am old enough now to better understand how and why this all plays out. We humans need certainty, predictability, and a foundation of understanding from which to build our lives. We like the idea of our God engineering and inspiring each and every word as the architect of the Bible. It’s something we can put our trust in. Understandably, we need something to rely on and count on. We don’t build or live in high-rise buildings unless we can believe that the architects and carpenters were trustworthy, competent, and experienced. I think it must be similar with the Bible for those people who want to build their lives on a perfect, inspired, God-breathed Word of God. Anything less would seems risky and uncertain. I totally get why the belief in the verbal inspiration of the Bible is so important to people.
As for me, I am thankful for this rugged imperfect map. I met Jesus when I unfolded this map on a road trip when I was 18. I can see the blood stains on one torn corner from the hands of Paul due to his selfless service. I can see a tear at the top from the idealism and practicality of James as he was moved by anger to action to stand up against rich landowners oppressing and abusing the poor. I can see the love of John in his poetry written in calligraphy on the back cover, and can only imagine he would have been a faithful, wise friend and perhaps the best husband a wife could wish for. I can see now that all these amazing men and women had such authentic character, courage, and faith that I can only conclude (choose to believe) that God was inspiring their lives. I just don’t believe God inspired each and every actual, literal, written-down word. That way, God is not made out to be a murderer/weatherman/nautical engineer. He doesn’t care at all about the sacrifice of animals and where their blood should be sprinkled, etc. He doesn’t tell people to pillage towns after winning a war. There is nothing perfect or inspired about those stories and beliefs.
At the end of the day, I can only hope that the same God that I believe inspired the determination, love, courageous action and faith of those first Christ-followers, will inspire me as a Christ-follower so that my life will inspire the lives of my wife, my children, my friends and family and community. Now open your map and keep on living this great adventure of faith.
Maybe Dennis Miller was right in his rant: The idea of being forced to read a smudged, torn, stained map in the middle of a road trip with a flashlight with dying batteries, forces us to “…huddle together in community for warmth in existential darkness, and in the process, bringing all of us closer together. Or maybe I am just a f$#%ing moron.”
7 comments
Mar 26, 2010
tim says:
Very well written post. There are many Christians (even biblical scholars) who would categorize much of the historical narrative elements of the Torah (especially Genesis) as myth, so you are not alone there, nor do I think those beliefs make you any less of a Christian.
I am curious how holding these beliefs has impacted your relationship with other Christians? Do you still go to church? If so, how do other believers react to your stance on scripture (if they know)?
Mar 26, 2010
emergentcoach says:
It has impacted my relationship with other Christians only to the degree that I disclose my ideas about these topics (which is only with select trusted friends). There are few church going people who would agree with me. I have yet to really “come out” but it is coming to the point where I actually believe some people could benefit from my honesty about these issues – it might be freeing for them in some ways. I very rarely go to church these days. Thanks for your thougths! Dave
Apr 12, 2010
rosacola says:
I appreciate your honesty – “…some people could benefit from my honesty about these issues…” True enough.
I am finding myself questioning the ‘infallible word’ these days. I too have studied that there are other letters that never made in into the ‘bible’. Also, it was written by men, imperfect, fallen, men.
It doesn’t change my view of who God is. It helps me rely on His presence in my life rather then a book written 2000 years ago.
Anyway, thanks for sharing your heart here.
Apr 17, 2010
newepiphany says:
You have come face to face with many truths. You no longer choose to live in an alternate reality like many of your born-again, evangelical friends, and I suspect family members as well. Has your personal journey not also resulted in a questioning of the Jesus Christ resurrection story, which is truly the very foundation of Christianity itself?
Have you been able to hang on to Jesus as savior and Lord while rejecting the o.t. as being the word of God?
To me, when I could no longer reconcile Yahweh-god to Jesus-god in something called a Holy Trinity, the whole premise of Jesus as the Son of God/Yahweh, sent to die for my sins and bring me eternal life started to fall apart very quickly. IOW, if I reject Yahweh as the creator god of the universe, how do I hold on to Christ as the savior of mankind?
I lived in that alternate reality of evangelical Christianity for 30 years, so I very much identify with those still there, especially my sweet family members whom I love dearly. I feel very free, but they just can’t understand how anyone can live or love without Jesus in his heart. I am still the same loving husband and dad/granddad as before, but I just choose to live in the reality that the bible was written by men, not God.
newepiphany
Apr 22, 2010
emergentcoach says:
Newepiphany – thanks for your comments. Living in the reality that the bible was written by men, not God is a good place to be. I too live in that reality. I was watching the National Geographic special about Stephen Hawking and his “Theory of Everything” and I was reminded (once again) that I live in the reality of a universe created by a really, really smart God. I like that reality too.
Aug 26, 2010
thin-ice says:
Emergentcoach,
I just read your story in August, 2010. You may never see this, but if you do, I have some questions for you, as a fellow Multnomah grad (Th.B., 1971).
I have completely de-converted in the last 3 years. Currently an agnostic, a paused briefly – for 6 months or less – at the “emergent” stage, then at the liberal stage, then deist, and now (and probably where I’ll remain) at agnostic. In the past 4 decades, I have been a missionary in Europe, deacon, youth group leader, or always in some way involved in church. I may post my story here, although the site seems to be moribund at present.
My questions have to do with this: now that you’ve stripped your deity of his christian trappings, do you find the remaining deity satisfying, either intellectually, or emotionally? How can you be sure “he” exists, if he is not the personal god as portrayed in the N.T.? If you think he is a personal god who listens to your prayers, how can you verify that?
OK, with those questions out of the way, just one last item: I would love to hook up with other Multnomah grads who have de-converted or left the faith. I moved back to Portland, but I’m trying to shield my fundamentalist mother from the fact that her eldest son is apostate! So I’ve got to be a little cautious how I do it, but if you know of anyone else, I would like to get in touch.
Take care . . .
Dec 30, 2011
gnilrets says:
There are many who, of course, would say that it’s impossible to believe in God’s existence, but not in the bible. However, I’ve made the same differentiation. As a 38 year believer who attended for 35 of those years before leaving the church, I know it’s not fun being in the apostate category. It’s rather frightening. However, I’m more frightened of going back to the illusionary safe zone. On the topic of divine inspiration of the bible then, I remind myself that no mortal man has the qualifications to authenticate or deauthenticate the divinity of a literary work, not even a Nicean council of world-renowned scholars with an agenda. I know God exists and hope to understand him better before I die. I try to remember always that this is a personal pursuit, and that the church isn’t a reliable resource in this pursuit. Thanks for being honest with us and reminding us all that rejecting the things we were taught about the bible does not equal a total relinquishment of God.